← All posts

2026-11-11 · 5 min read · Livingston

Should You Waive the Appraisal Contingency in Livingston, TN? An Appraiser's View

Calculator on a table beside paperwork

What the appraisal contingency actually does

I'm Bridget Salazar, OC Homegirl, a REALTOR® with The Realty Firm and a Certified Residential Appraiser in Livingston, TN.

Buyers ask me whether they should waive the appraisal contingency, and the question comes up most when more than one person wants the same house. I answer it from two chairs. One is the agent writing your offer. The other is the appraiser who has spent 14 years deciding what property is worth.

Start with what the contingency is. It is a condition in your offer that ties the deal to the appraised value. If the appraisal lands under the contract price, the contingency gives you a defined way to renegotiate or to step out, instead of being locked into a price the lender will not fully fund.

What it allows in your deal is written in the contract you sign, and that language is the only version that counts. This article is general information, not legal or lending advice. Your attorney reads the contract and your lender decides what your loan permits.

What you give up when you waive it

Waiving the contingency does not make the appraisal go away. If your loan calls for one, the lender still orders it.

What goes away is your protection. The lender sizes your loan off the appraised value, so a value under the contract price opens a gap between what you promised to pay and what the bank will lend. You just agreed to be the one who closes that gap.

  • Cash. The gap gets covered with your money, on top of your down payment and your closing costs.
  • Your exit. Leaving may now cost you your earnest money, depending on what the contract says.
  • Your leverage. A seller has little reason to move on price when you have already promised to pay it.
  • Equity on day one. You own a house that was valued under what you paid for it.

That last one lands harder than buyers expect. Paying over the appraised value is not automatically a mistake, and sometimes it is the right call. It should be a decision you made on purpose, though, not something you learn about two weeks before closing. The seller's side of the same problem is in what happens if the appraisal comes in low.

How I size up the risk before you sign anything

This is the part of the question I can answer differently than most agents can.

Before you waive anything, I run the same comparable sales work an appraiser will run later. Recent closed sales, adjusted for acreage, square footage, condition and the buildings on the place. Then I show you where the contract price sits against that work.

What I hand you is a pricing opinion built with appraisal methods. It is not a formal appraisal, and those are two different assignments.

Three answers come out of it, and they point three different directions.

  • The price is well supported. The risk of a low number is small, and waiving costs you little.
  • The price sits at the top of what the sales support. The risk is real, and at least now you can size it.
  • The price is above anything I can support. I will tell you that plainly, whether or not it is what you wanted to hear.

Property across Overton County makes this harder than it would be in a subdivision. Acreage, outbuildings and long private drives all hand the appraiser more judgment calls. Put two careful appraisers on the same acreage property and you can get two defensible numbers that are not the same. A wide range is exactly when I do not want you giving up your protection.

The middle option most buyers never hear about

Waiving is not the only move available. You can cap it instead.

Rather than removing the contingency, a buyer can agree to cover a shortfall up to an amount they name, and keep the contingency below that line. You pick the number off cash you actually have, not off hope.

That gives the seller most of what they were after, which is confidence the deal survives a low number. It gives you a floor. If the appraisal comes in further under than the amount you named, you are back inside your contingency.

Whether that structure is available in your deal, and exactly how it gets written, is a question for the contract and your attorney. Your lender also has to be fine with where the extra cash comes from, so ask them before you write the offer.

When waiving makes sense, and when it does not

I won't give you a blanket answer, because this one is about your money and a specific house.

Waiving can be reasonable when:

  • You have cash set aside for a gap and losing it would not change your life.
  • The sales support the price, and you have seen the sales I read it against.
  • You plan to own the house a long time, so a short-term value question matters less.
  • The property is ordinary for the area, with a comparable sale down the road.

I would not waive it when:

  • The gap money is your emergency fund or your moving money.
  • The property is unusual, which describes a lot of what sells around here.
  • You are already stretched to the top of your approval.
  • Nobody has shown you the sales behind the asking price.

If you are using a VA or FHA loan there is another layer, because those appraisals carry rules of their own and what you are allowed to agree to becomes a lender question. Veterans and service members can start on my VA and military buyers page. If this is your first house, read first-time buyers, and the full order of operations is on how I help buyers.

What this looks like from the seller's side

Sellers like a waived appraisal contingency, and they are right to. It removes one of the ways a contract dies.

It is not free, though. A buyer who promised to cover a gap can still run out of money, and a deal that collapses late puts your house back on the market with days on it and a story attached.

So when I'm on the listing side, I read that offer for whether the buyer can do what they just promised. Proof of the funds for the gap. A lender who already knows about it. A term written clearly enough that nobody argues over it later.

The better fix is further upstream. Price the house where the sales support it and a low appraisal mostly stops being the thing you negotiate against. That is what a home value review is for, and it is the first step of selling your home in Livingston.

Tell me which house it is

Before you waive anything, let me pull the sales on that specific property and tell you where the price sits. Call or text me at (931) 510-1346, or send me a note here.

You get the number the sales support and the range around it. Then you can make the call with your own math in front of you, which beats making it against a deadline.

Watch me explain it

What happens if the appraisal comes in low?

The method

Where this fits in how i sell