2026-11-21 · 4 min read · Livingston
How to Read a Comparative Market Analysis Before You List in Livingston

The report that decides your price
I'm Bridget Salazar, OC Homegirl. I'm a REALTOR® with The Realty Firm and a Certified Residential Appraiser, and I work across Livingston and the rest of the Upper Cumberland.
Before you list, somebody is going to hand you a comparative market analysis. Most sellers call it a CMA.
It usually arrives as a stack of pages with a number on the front. A lot of sellers flip to that number, nod, and never read the rest.
The rest is where the number comes from. If you can read it, you can tell whether the price you're about to set is built on anything. Here is how I read one, in the order I read it.
What a CMA is, and what it is not
A CMA is an agent's analysis of what your home should sell for, built from properties that have already sold near you.
It is not an appraisal. An appraisal is a separate assignment with its own standards and its own written report, usually ordered by a lender once a home is under contract.
When I'm your listing agent, the number I give you is a pricing opinion built with appraisal methods, not a formal appraisal. I say that every time. The methods are the same ones I use in appraisal work, which is why I show you the sales instead of just handing over a figure.
It isn't an online estimate either. An algorithm has never been inside your house, and in Overton County, where most homes sit on land, it has very little to work with. Your county tax value is a third number again, built for a different purpose.
Read the comps first, not the price
Turn past the cover page and find the sold properties. That list is the whole argument.
For each one, check four things:
- When it sold. A closed sale from last month tells you more than one from two years ago.
- Where it sits, and whether it's the same kind of setting. A house in town and a house on ten acres are not the same property.
- Acreage and square footage, both measured against yours.
- Condition and age, as far as the report describes them.
Then ask the question that matters. Would a buyer looking seriously at your home have considered this one instead? If the answer is no, it isn't a comp, no matter how convenient the price is.
Around Livingston most homes sit on large lots or acreage, and most of what sells runs $250,000 to $450,000. Treat that as a range for a market, not a number for a house. Your house is its own question.
Then read the adjustments
A CMA with three sale prices and no adjustments is a list, not an analysis.
No two properties match, so every difference has to be accounted for. More acreage, a finished basement, a shop building, a newer roof, a carport where the other house had a garage. Each one moves the number up or down against yours.
What I look for is whether the report shows that work. A good one tells you what got added, what got subtracted, and why.
Acreage is where this goes wrong most often here. You can't take one neighbor's per-acre sale and multiply it across a bigger tract, and price per acre versus price per square foot explains why. Outbuildings are the other one, and barns, shops and outbuildings rarely add what they cost to put up.
Sold, pending and active tell you three different things
Most CMAs mix all three together. Keep them separate in your head, because they answer different questions.
- Sold is evidence. Somebody actually paid that, and with a loan involved an appraiser usually agreed.
- Pending is the newest information in the report. The price is agreed but not closed, so read it as a strong signal rather than proof.
- Active is not evidence at all. An asking price is a hope until a buyer signs something.
Active listings still matter, for a different reason. They're what your buyer walks through the same weekend as yours, so they set what your home gets compared against.
Look for one more group while you're in there. Listings that expired without selling are your ceiling. Somebody already tested that price and no buyer agreed.
Six questions to ask before you set the price
You don't have to be an appraiser to pressure-test a CMA. Ask these six.
- Why these comparable sales and not others? What got left out?
- What did you adjust for, and by how much?
- How many of these are closed sales rather than asking prices?
- What hasn't sold at this price, and why?
- If we list here, what is the first week supposed to look like?
- Where would an appraiser push back on this number?
An agent who priced with real data can answer all six without flinching. What your home is worth walks through the method I use, and home values in Livingston covers this market specifically.
Send me your address and I'll build you one
If you want a CMA you can actually read, send me your address. I'll pull the closed sales, show you the adjustments, and tell you what I think your home sells for and why I think it.
There's no obligation to list anything. Plenty of people want the number before they decide, and that's a reasonable place to start. When you're ready to go, selling your home and how I sell lay out the rest in order.
Call or text me at (931) 510-1346, or send me a note here. Tell me your address and roughly when you want to be moved.
Loan questions go to your lender. Deed and title questions go to your attorney, and tax questions to your CPA. The contract sets the terms.